I have the Sumitoma HTR 200 and have no complaints.

If you live in an area with little to no snow, then hands down that is the way to go. If you live in an area such as me where we get lots of snow during the winter month, then you are going to need a set of snows. The Sumitoma will not work in the snow. But since all weather tire suck equally at everything, I decided to buy 2 sets of tires, one for the winter month, and the Sumitoma for the rest of the year. Therefore I get the best of both worlds. In the winter my car handles like it is on rails and in the summer month my car can drive through monsoon like conditions (where as my OEM Dunlops were all over the road).