One could argue that the Insight is more unique and just as special. The Insight is the first production hybrid, it is one of only a few aluminium cars, production is limited adding uniqueness, and it is (and has been) the highest mileage car available in the US. Hybrids are way cool, if you are into such things. In your case you honestly seem to already have your mind made up. The Mini does have a "coolness' to it. Personally I'd rather have the Insight but I'm not you. You gotta make your own choices.