Based on your post, assuming you could fit in one (I can't, at 6'4" 250#), the Prius would probably be better suited to your situation. That said, you're still getting better mileage than someone in a non-hybrid, and your first two or three tanks are always rather crummy (Mine first was 41, my last two were 50), and it'll also get better as the summer heats up (as long as you don't crank up the a/c).

Someday I might even beat that wascally kenny!

No whammies... no whammies... no whammies...