View Single Post
  #5 (permalink)  
Old 06-29-2006, 11:15 AM
nbalthaser's Avatar
nbalthaser nbalthaser is offline
Active Enthusiast
 
Real Name: neil balthaser
Location: oakland, ca.
Hybrids: 06 hch w/navi (opal)
Posts: 163
Default Re: Help! Bob/anyone, Is HSD a variable ratio transmission?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Double-Trinity
It's a tough pick, it is always in top gear along the mechanical path, however, the amount of power that follows that path is continuously variable, so it does vary the torque that is transmitted just as if there were real gears, or a pulley/cone system.

i'm by no means an expert on hsd but technically, isn't the torque ratio fixed at about 72% to sun gear 38% to ring gear? it's the power that is variable right?

also, i don't understand how you're defining "variable ratio" and "transmission". some would argue that psd isn't really even a transmission.

one challenge i see in trying to categorize psd as cvt is that at higher road speeds (lets say greater than 80mph), the motor/generator attached to the sun gear (mg2?) is going to consume more and more power as speed increases thus requiring more power from the ice at maybe 30% inefficiency. that means the ice is going to have to work harder to provide the power. this quirk gives me pause when considering psd a true cvt. obviously a belt and pulley cvt doesn't have this problem.

so at lower speeds, psd appears to act like a traditional cvt but at higher highway speeds it starts acting less and less like one. i would imagine there is a speed limit where mpg drops precipitously b/c the ice is working so hard to overcome the inefficiencies of the mechanical->electrical->chemical->electrical->mechanical energy conversions.

like i said, i'm not fully an expert on psd but this latter point merits discussion i would think.

.


Last edited by nbalthaser : 06-29-2006 at 02:37 PM. Reason: got my gears mixed up!
Reply With Quote