I've have cloth and would have preferred leather but my wife and son vetoed that. The cloth (grey ash) is good looking and has been easy to keep clean (a few smudges have wiped right off). I, personally, wouldn't agonize over the decision. You'll soon get accustomed to whatever covering you've chosen and neither will detract from your enjoyment of the car, which is sensational, no matter how its equipped.

Good Luck!