Neither, over the years I have owned both as well as Goodyear, Dunlop, Pirelli and Yokohama. My favorite tire that combines all season handling with performance is the Yokohama Avid H4. Michelin relies on their name more than quality. The 'Yokos' have a 500 AA treadwear rating and a 60k treadwear warranty. I have them in 18" on my Camry and any treadwear warranty in that size is unheard of. The only reason I would ever look elsewhere is if that stop manufacturing them. Good luck. Jon.