I just returned from a long road trip in my HCH, using three full tanks of gas, and got:

- 48mpg going 70-75 on the 1st leg
- 54mpg going 60-65 through southern california
- 45mpg going 75 coming home

My three other highway trips, going about 65mph (the speed limit), yielded 49, 51, and 52mpg. So I'm not sure how you could get mileage so low as you mention on your test drive. You can look at this mileage database to get some real numbers from other HCH owners.

Right now when I pay moderate attention to mileage in my short 6-mile city commute I get between 43-46mpg. When I just buzz around in a more impatient manner I seem to get closer to 42mpg.

I agree with previous posters regarding Prius versus Civic. IMO, they are both great cars. The Prius will give you a larger car, more horsepower, and (as listed on GreenHybrid DB) about 2mpg more than the Civic. You will probably pay about 3-5K more for the car, versus a comparably equipped Civic. You will get the cool look of the Prius and the gratification of driving an instantly recognizable hybrid car. I have friends with both types of hybrids, and all really, really love their cars.

Regarding the ride and responsiveness of the Civic Hybrid: I previously owned a 2002 Civic Si (the hatchback), a sporty car with a 2.0L engine. I much prefer the hybrid, both in handling and acceleration. The acceleration is quick and noiseless; and on the highway, it seems like the car doesn't even have to try in order to pass.

That's just my opinion, of course, but I was just thinking on my trip that I enjoy this car in almost every way imaginable: fuel economy, ride, handling, and interior comforts. Now if only it had an MP3 plug like the Element...