View Single Post
  #12 (permalink)  
Old 03-29-2005, 07:48 PM
tdmsu tdmsu is offline
Enthusiast
 
Real Name: Paul
Location: D.C. Area
Hybrids: Still Shopping...
Posts: 31
Default

Hi xcel,

Thanks for the advice... I'll try it and report the results. Another oil question... does using an oil different from what is called for pose any risks? Any long-term wear issues? If not, why don't all cars already use some form of 0w20?

I test drove an Accord Hybrid, a VW Passat TDI, and a VW Jetta TDI today. I took each on the identical 12 mile combination city/highway trip. I've been reading lots about diesel claims vs. hybrids, so I thought I'd do a little research. (I still could not find an Insight or decent Prius to drive)

The MPG champ was the Passat - it had a 2.0L TDI 4cyl - I got approximately 37MPG for the trip, with long streches on the highway at 65MPH getting 46MPG using cruise. The only problem I had with it were not mechanical, but stylistic.... the dash looks cheap, cheap, cheap...

The Jetta was similar to the Passat, but I had no way of getting a MPG reading - no trip computer or anything. Same cheap looking controls.

The Accord was as smooth as a dream, and I was able to make 33MPG for the trip despite not realizing the salesman turned on the AC before I left. It screams quality and refinement. I also got to play with the Nav system (although it was the version for the Odyessy... it is similar) - very cool! The handling and acceleration between the Passat and Accord are also very similar, but the Accord has a nicer ride.

The VW salesman told me that the TDI runs cleaner than a hybrid, and beats in everyway. If it were not for the sulphur emissions of the TDI, I might have gone with one despite the chincy interior. The Passat is much less expensive than the Accord (something like $6000), but does not sacrifice in economy or driving experience. The Accord makes up for the cost IMHO through reduced emissions.

I think I'll go with the Accord, but I still have about a month to be obsessive about this...

p
Reply With Quote