I have had my HCH with CVT, a California AT-PZEV (which gets the worst MPG of all 4 of the HCHs) for 12 months.
My lifetime average is 58.7 MPG.
My worst tank was 52 MPG, my first.
My best tank was 62.4 MPG last summer.
My last tank was my first over 60 this year now that the weather is more dry and warm.
99% of the time I drive alone with no air conditioner.
I always use cruise control.
I don't worrry about lean burn or driving with the load and still get superb MPGs.
All that other stuff is too much hassle for me and I am happy with my MPG.
There are two reasons I don't like to drive with passengers.
They weigh something, lowers my MPG.
I drive a bit more like a normal driver, which lowers my MPG.
See if one of your friends can drive at lunch.
It will be worse for the planet, but better for your MPG.
I bought several cases of Mobile1 synthetic 0w20 before it went out of production.
If you look in an auto parts store in a poor neighborhood they may still have some.
That is where I found mine.
Not many hybrids in poor neighborhoods, perhaps.
I heard Penzoil has a hybrid oil, but I know nothing about it.
I do my own oil changes so it never overfills, which hurts MPG.
When I do a service interval at the dealer I give them *exactly* enough oil so they can't overfill.
Tires at 40 psi, checked every other week, and after visits to the dealer.
They set it back down to 32 psi.
I leave early so I never have to rush.
The panel under the engine is to give the air a smoother surface to flow over.
This lowers drag, increasing MPG.
Keep it on.
Replace it if damaged.
I read somewhere if you are going over 45
MPH close the windows and turn the AC on if it is hot.
Under 45
MPH open the windows and turn the AC off.
This is for the best MPG.
Also try wearing less and lighter clothes.
My commute is 17.2 miles on the freeway.
I think 12 miles is too short to drive much after the car is warmed up.
Move further from work.
YMMV