well, I opted for the honda.
I do have a history of buying them
- 87 crx si (deceased)
- 90 civic dx (still on the road - my brother drives it!)
- 99 vfr
- 00 s2000
- 05 HCH
and yes, I've REALLY like them all. Honda's engineering seems fantastic.
With that said, I also have an 02 Toyota Tundra, and couldn't be more happy with it (my very first truck, which serves as a wood hauler, etc.)
I had no preconceived notions and test drove both the Prius II and the HCH - as a purpose built car for commuting. I would have purchased an Insight, but my wife wouldn't let me (the argument being 2 cars with only 2 seats is not practical)
So... it came down to mileage, and a 5 speed tranny. Folks getting better mileage with the Priuses may be true, but not for my commuting style - I don't have a lot of stop and go. Now that the weather is warming up and I've figured out how to drive the car to maximize fuel efficiency, I'm EASILY able to get 55 MPG per tank. It'll probably take some tank fulls until my signature catches up though. I'm hopeful my next tank will get me 700 miles and into the 60s. My best trip so far was 67 MPG and I just don't see this happening with a Prius.
What I don't like about the HCH:
- The rear seats don't fold down, but I'd probably never use this car for this purpose anyway.
- Things hit me

I've had the car for 4 months and was rear ended and also assaulted by a deer. . . ok, maybe this has nothing to do with being a Honda
- The stock radio is weak, and I'm in process of major upgrades because I like high fidelity in a car (based on a post above, I wouldn't be able to do this w/ a Prius)
- The gas pedal position isn't ideal for leaving my leg in a comfortable position to "feather" the throttle. I move the seat way back to compensate . . . this is probably a personal thing.
- My wife now complains that I drive WAY TOO slow

- No sunroof - what's up with that??
My cooworkers are all keen on it, and they are looking to go hybrid now too!
- Laterz, Josh