That makes very good sense, BUT even on ice cold days, eventually the engine gets up to temp. Hard to think the oil could make THAT large a difference. I have used syn oil in mine and never noticed what yours is doing.
Seeing as you didnt post the yr of your HAH, it does seem like the 12v battery in a couple of 05's have died for one reason or another. Perhaps, if thats low, the engine feels it needs to be running to keep the 12v system charged as a priority?
Be sure to know your radio security code before disconnecting your 12v battery.
Here is where my temp gauge sits when 76 outside
