Re: Trip Computer Errors
One thought on another source of error- someone mentioned tread wear, etc. Along that line: HAH tires are 16 inch 215/60 vs 16 inch 205/60 on the regular. That translates into ~1% difference in circumference...for the same # of revolutions, you will travel about 1% further than someone in a regular V6 Accord. So if Honda forgot to recalibrate the odo for the fatter tires (a big if- we're talking HONDA engineers here), one could expect the dash FE readout to be ~.3mpg lower than the navi readout, assuming you're working around 30mpg in general and you take GPS distance to be groundtruth. Doesn't account for it all, and it actually is contrary to the odo distance being shorter than GPS distance, but hey, I'm just tossing this into the arena here. Just another possible source of error.
Not knowing how frequently GPS updates its fix and what method it uses to determine distance between fixes, I can't add much to the discussion about why GPS distance seems higher than odo distance- but remember EACH fix can be off by ~10 meters (I think), adding up to 20meters for each distance calculation. Its very unlikely that situation would occur- a nearly constant error over short distances is more common (thus the birth of differential GPS to correct a slowly time-varying error that is constant over a local area)
Too many 'what ifs' and some may cancel others, leaving no single cause as the dominant reason for a smallish persistent offset. The only way to find out which distance is correct (or less wrong) is to find a known measured straight road, drive it, and compare. That's how you do it in a boat- calibrate on a measured mile.
Not having a navi in my HAH, this is all academic to me, for now.
Last edited by gonavy : 06-17-2005 at 08:51 AM.
|