Electric Vehicle Forums

Electric Vehicle Forums (/forums/)
-   Honda Accord Hybrid (https://electricvehicleforums.com/forums/honda-accord-hybrid-27/)
-   -   Accord Hybrid - AC refrigerant question (https://electricvehicleforums.com/forums/honda-accord-hybrid-27/accord-hybrid-ac-refrigerant-question-30832/)

j2ram 06-19-2016 01:36 PM

Accord Hybrid - AC refrigerant question
 
hello - got 07 Accord Hybrid. AC is fine except for hot summer months where it takes extra long time to cool down. Tending to think it is refrigerant issue. By looking at the fine print of R134a refrigerant can (ACPRO in autozone), got to know they are not compatible with Hybrid vehicle.

Here is better explanation of why-

http://hondakarma.com/threads/hybrid...65/live?page=1

Does anyone have an experience here for Honda Hybrid vehicles (2nd gen Civic hybrid or Accord Hybrid) on what product to buy / refill the AC refrigerant?

Getting to dealership is the last option, hoping someone had gone thru this refill process.

S Keith 06-20-2016 09:48 PM

Re: Accord Hybrid - AC refrigerant question
 
Have serviced 2X HCH2 with the hybrid pulley/electric compressor including compressor replacement, evac and recharge.

Buy the $4.88 can of SuperTech STRAIGHT R-134a from Walmart.

The issue is the oil. It takes a magic oil that's ridiculously expensive but completely non-conductive unlike the typical PAG oil in servicing kits or systems.

Plain R-134a WITHOUT oil or any kind of o-ring sealant is absolutely fine. Use a NEW filler hose or manifold gauge set that has never been attached to a traditional R-134a system.

gafortiby 06-21-2016 10:15 AM

Re: Accord Hybrid - AC refrigerant question
 
Hm I just made the potentially expensive mistake of putting some AC PRO R134a which has PAG oil and additives into my HCH2. The AC is blowing 5 degrees cooler now, but seems like this was a big mistake on my part so I am going to take it into a shop to see if they can flush it with POE or vacuum and recharge. The shop says they can do Hybrid compressors and seem to think that vacuum and charge is the way to go.

Honda Factory Service manual (should have read this before I went to walmart!) says to replace every component of the AC system if there is any contamination with non-spec oil but that seems like total overkill. That includes compressor, condenser, evap, etc. As far as I can tell, the PAG oil will damage the compressor windings and therefore potentially cause shocks, but I am not sure why a flush and charge would not be sufficient to recover the insulating properties.

I wonder if I should take it to the dealer instead, but that would be super expensive and they might actually want me to follow the factory procedure.

S Keith 06-21-2016 10:27 AM

Re: Accord Hybrid - AC refrigerant question
 

Originally Posted by gafortiby (Post 260000)
Hm I just made the potentially expensive mistake of putting some AC PRO R134a which has PAG oil and additives into my HCH2. The AC is blowing 5 degrees cooler now, but seems like this was a big mistake on my part so I am going to take it into a shop to see if they can flush it with POE or vacuum and recharge. The shop says they can do Hybrid compressors and seem to think that vacuum and charge is the way to go.

Honda Factory Service manual (should have read this before I went to walmart!) says to replace every component of the AC system if there is any contamination with non-spec oil but that seems like total overkill. As far as I can tell, the PAG oil will damage the compressor windings and therefore potentially cause shocks, but I am not sure why a flush and charge would not be sufficient to recover the insulating properties.

I wonder if I should take it to the dealer instead, but that would be super expensive and they might actually want me to follow the factory procedure.

I wish they would change their warning from the tiny print at the bottom of the can.

Dealer wanted $2K to replace only the compressor. I don't think the dealer is an option.

Damage occurs and it's almost impossible to completely clear the system of contamimated oil.

Flushing the system of contaminants is a challenge in a normal system. Do it with Honda oil will make you crap your pants. That stuff is expensive.

You might try the oil that claims to be compatible as a flushing fluid.

gafortiby 06-21-2016 11:28 AM

Re: Accord Hybrid - AC refrigerant question
 
I should look for a flush, but I don't think it is as bad as the service manual says. Here's a company that did a experience by deliberately using PAG oil in a Prius and it was fine at least for the few days they tested it.
http://www.fixhybrid.com/comp-oil/

After all, PAG still has 1Mohm resistance whereas POE has 10Mohm. The actual problem appears to be the speculation that PAG will degrade the insulation on the windings.

In fact I cannot find a single case of IMA light coming on due to PAG oil in the AC line, the only references are in the service manual and people speculating. not a single case of an actual documented instance.

S Keith 06-21-2016 11:56 AM

Re: Accord Hybrid - AC refrigerant question
 

Originally Posted by gafortiby (Post 260004)
I should look for a flush, but I don't think it is as bad as the service manual says. Here's a company that did a experience by deliberately using PAG oil in a Prius and it was fine at least for the few days they tested it.
http://www.fixhybrid.com/comp-oil/

After all, PAG still has 1Mohm resistance whereas POE has 10Mohm. The actual problem appears to be the speculation that PAG will degrade the insulation on the windings.

In fact I cannot find a single case of IMA light coming on due to PAG oil in the AC line, the only references are in the service manual and people speculating. not a single case of an actual documented instance.

Not sure about HCH2, but check prius chat. Since I started reading there 9/2015, I recall at least one compressor failure following contamination. I looked at a local Prius on Craigslist where they're compressor wasn't working with a P0AA6 code that tripped a few months after they used a charge kit not intended for hybrids.

The Prius compressor is higher voltage and much higher power than the HCH2 as it's pure electric and likely more susceptible than the IMA system.

It's absolutely worth trying to flush first. I suspect correction shortly after contamination with minimal use between will likely resolve it.

gafortiby 06-21-2016 12:02 PM

Re: Accord Hybrid - AC refrigerant question
 

Originally Posted by S Keith (Post 260005)
Not sure about HCH2, but check prius chat. Since I started reading there 9/2015, I recall at least one compressor failure following contamination. I looked at a local Prius on Craigslist where they're compressor wasn't working with a P0AA6 code that tripped a few months after they used a charge kit not intended for hybrids.

The Prius compressor is higher voltage and much higher power than the HCH2 as it's pure electric and likely more susceptible than the IMA system.

It's absolutely worth trying to flush first. I suspect correction shortly after contamination with minimal use between will likely resolve it.


Thanks!

Well it the headaches of my own stupidity + owning a hybrid is rearing its head a bit here.

I have 2 local shops that I love and use often. 1st shop I called was not aware that hybrids required a different oil, and when I pressed into the details the service writer talked to the technician and then I was told I need to go to Honda because they can't service the special oil. :(
2nd shop who was a Honda-only shop for 20 years told me that they can do flush and charge, but the tech says I should be using PAG oil. I said Honda factory service manual calls for POE and they said the service manual must be outdated. :omg:

I'm gonna call the Honda dealer now. Times like this I wish I lived in a more crunchy granola area.

S Keith 06-21-2016 12:17 PM

Re: Accord Hybrid - AC refrigerant question
 

Originally Posted by gafortiby (Post 260006)
Thanks!

Well it the headaches of my own stupidity + owning a hybrid is rearing its head a bit here.

I have 2 local shops that I love and use often. 1st shop I called was not aware that hybrids required a different oil, and when I pressed into the details the service writer talked to the technician and then I was told I need to go to Honda because they can't service the special oil. :(
2nd shop who was a Honda-only shop for 20 years told me that they can do flush and charge, but the tech says I should be using PAG oil. I said Honda factory service manual calls for POE and they said the service manual must be outdated. :omg:

I'm gonna call the Honda dealer now. Times like this I wish I lived in a more crunchy granola area.

Run from those shops. Branch out and try to find shops familiar with hybrid a/c systems.

gafortiby 06-21-2016 01:39 PM

Re: Accord Hybrid - AC refrigerant question
 

Originally Posted by S Keith (Post 260007)
Run from those shops. Branch out and try to find shops familiar with hybrid a/c systems.

Funny thing. Local dealer says, "It's fine, don't worry about it."

I think I put in about 3 oz (not sure if wt or fl) of the ACPRO. MSDS says 5~15vol% of this is PAG. So then i'm looking at about 0.3 oz of PAG oil, with ~4oz of original oil I have 10% contamination? Given the strong language in the service manual seems like even 1% contamination requires system replacement.

Dealer says if I want to, I can ask for a vacuum and fill for $180.

AC is still blowing 45degrees F :shade:
I suppose is the car blows up next week it'd be sad. :omg:

S Keith 06-21-2016 01:53 PM

Re: Accord Hybrid - AC refrigerant question
 

Originally Posted by gafortiby (Post 260008)
Funny thing. Local dealer says, "It's fine, don't worry about it."

I think I put in about 3 oz (not sure if wt or fl) of the ACPRO. MSDS says 5~15vol% of this is PAG. So then i'm looking at about 0.3 oz of PAG oil, with ~4oz of original oil I have 10% contamination? Given the strong language in the service manual seems like even 1% contamination requires system replacement.

Dealer says if I want to, I can ask for a vacuum and fill for $180.

AC is still blowing 45degrees F :shade:
I suppose is the car blows up next week it'd be sad. :omg:

I almost like your dealer. $180 is a great price for a dealer evacuation and charge. The oil alone is $60 for 50mL. Personally, I'd do it.

gafortiby 06-23-2016 02:14 PM

Re: Accord Hybrid - AC refrigerant question
 

Originally Posted by S Keith (Post 260009)
I almost like your dealer. $180 is a great price for a dealer evacuation and charge. The oil alone is $60 for 50mL. Personally, I'd do it.

Dealer now says full vacuum and recharge (so not necessarily flush but it's good enough for me on a ten year old car) is $165 with labor and parts combined. They are not recommending any parts replacement.

Going in next week! :)

AC still blowing 45 degrees.

gafortiby 06-28-2016 02:37 PM

Re: Accord Hybrid - AC refrigerant question
 
The dealer did the AC evac and recharge service, and assured me many times that the work was done properly for my car and they know it is a hybrid.

But I am beginning to distrust every mechanic in the world because the service advisor could only tell me that R134A is the correct fluid. I kept asking about the compressor oil but no real answers besides "R134A" is the correct one. "The important thing is that it has the "A" behind R134." No mention of SE-10Y oil or electrical properties.

Plus they added R134A Dye, again no mention of whether this is the correct Tracerline dye or something else. At this point I would like to submit my car as the official guinea pig test car of potentially contaminated AC compressor oil.

S Keith 06-28-2016 06:45 PM

Re: Accord Hybrid - AC refrigerant question
 
Wow. I'm a little dubious as well. However, most people making arrangements for the service don't necessarily know very much.

Hopeful that the actual technical people understand what is required.

Johnthompsonmd 06-06-2018 12:09 PM

Re: Accord Hybrid - AC refrigerant question
 
Hello my 05 Accord hybrid Ac stop work month before I took to my mechanic told me to go to dealer and checked out they found compressor lock and a hole in condenser they wants $1700 for parts + labor but I ordered both parts from a accidental car condenser with dryer and compressor Now I need ur help I can take to my mechanic and install them? And what cautions need to this complete process pls help me thnx

seanehlert 10-04-2018 11:03 AM

Re: Accord Hybrid - AC refrigerant question
 

Originally Posted by gafortiby (Post 260058)
The dealer did the AC evac and recharge service, and assured me many times that the work was done properly for my car and they know it is a hybrid.

But I am beginning to distrust every mechanic in the world because the service advisor could only tell me that R134A is the correct fluid. I kept asking about the compressor oil but no real answers besides "R134A" is the correct one. "The important thing is that it has the "A" behind R134." No mention of SE-10Y oil or electrical properties.

Plus they added R134A Dye, again no mention of whether this is the correct Tracerline dye or something else. At this point I would like to submit my car as the official guinea pig test car of potentially contaminated AC compressor oil.

gafortiby - I'm curious if you're still around and how everything worked out. I myself have put a can of AC Pro in my 2013 Acura ILX Hybrid. After doing so, I noticed the "not for hybrids with electric compressors" notice on the back. I didn't think much of it since I have a belt. I didn't realize the compressor itself was also a hybrid. Go figure. It was in my system for a good year (beginning of summer 2017) with no issues. After this summer, I'm having weird compressor shut down issues. I'm curious if your car survived the experience.

gafortiby 10-04-2018 01:19 PM

Re: Accord Hybrid - AC refrigerant question
 

Originally Posted by seanehlert (Post 266517)
gafortiby - I'm curious if you're still around and how everything worked out. I myself have put a can of AC Pro in my 2013 Acura ILX Hybrid. After doing so, I noticed the "not for hybrids with electric compressors" notice on the back. I didn't think much of it since I have a belt. I didn't realize the compressor itself was also a hybrid. Go figure. It was in my system for a good year (beginning of summer 2017) with no issues. After this summer, I'm having weird compressor shut down issues. I'm curious if your car survived the experience.

Hello,
My car is still working fine and AC is still blowing cold. I have not done anything to the AC since I had the dealer look at it when I posted my experiences.


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 09:35 AM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands